“Quality… you know what it is, yet you don’t know what it is. But that’s self-contradictory. But some things are better than others, that is, they have more quality. But when you try to say what that quality is, apart from the things that have it, it all goes poof! There’s nothing to talk about. But if you can’t say what Quality is, how do you know what it is, or how do you know that it even exists? If no one knows what it is, then for all practical purposes it doesn’t exist at all. But for all practical purposes it really does exist. What else are all the grades based on? Why else would people pay fortunes for some things and throw others in the trash pile? Obviously some things are better than others… but what’s the “betterness”?… So round and round you go, spinning mental wheels and nowhere finding anyplace to get traction. What the hell is Quality? What is it?”
Robert M. Persig, Zen And The Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance
I have been conducting the most unscientific survey ever over the last several days, asking people, “What is it that makes the difference for you between music that you absolutely love and music that you feel fine about?”
The most common face-to-face/non-internet response has been a blank look at the wall behind me, followed by something along the lines of “I don’t know, I just like it.”, then more staring, then another more surprised and incredulous, “I don’t know!” …I swear, most people are sincerely baffled when you ask them to answer this, and I’ve been ruminating on the topic myself, and so I feel compelled to write about this and how it relates to musical Quality with a capital Q.
(Also, interestingly, many people’s responses quickly resorted to telling me what they *didn’t* like and this seems to be much easier to talk about. It’s just articulating that difference between the middle of the sliding scale and the top of the sliding scale that seems to be difficult.)
Responses sent over the internet had the benefit of being voluntary (rather than being ambushed at work), and many thoughtful responses were given. The following themes emerged between the Internet responses and the compiled answers of the face-to-face guerrilla philosophy questioning:
- Strong emotional reaction (especially when being reminded of a specific time in your life)
- Evokes spiritual feelings & feelings of connection including empathy / ability to relate
- Certain preferred musical elements and their combinations: timing / harmonies / solos / rhythms / textures / instruments / vocal style, etc.
- Admiring the musician
- Authenticity / honesty
- Intriguing / innovative
- Ability to reliably bring you to a desired mood state or energy level
I heard the story once of when Frances Galton (you know, that English Victorian progressive / polymath / sociologist / psychologist / anthropologist / eugenicist / tropical explorer / geographer / inventor / meteorologist / proto-geneticist / psychometrician / statistician? Thanks Wikipedia.) …anyway he went to the county fair and observed that the crowd’s averaged guesses of the weight of an ox came much closer to the actual weight than any individual guess.
What’s funny is that as I’m looking at this list of the responses of a small smattering of people… all of the music I named yesterday for my Top 5 encompass all points of the list. So now I’m curious: if you were to name your Top 5 musicians/groups, how many of them would demonstrate all of this compiled list? The Totally Unscientific Survey continues!
In the name of community, bad science, curiosity, and self-promotion, I hereby invite you to share your top 5 musicians/groups (and favorite album) and how many of them check off all 7 Quality Points on the Olive Tiger Facebook page: www.facebook.com/olivetigermusic And then I will compile unreliable statistics to share.
Anyway…
So by defining its attributes, have we nailed down Quality in music? Is the sum of our crowd-wise responses sufficient to describe What Makes for Quality Music?
Ahh, right. Neglecting the individual again. Not everyone agrees on what Quality Music is.
For instance, I have recently been challenged on my broad-brush disdain of music that features the heavy “boom-bap-boom-bap” 80’s drum beat, which has given me complicated love-hate relationships with bands like the Talking Heads, which has further made me wonder, why do I hate that beat so much? (I have no good answer yet, except that I find it boring, but boring alone doesn’t account for my hatred of that beat.)
Of course there are a million little things consciously and subconsciously informing these kinds of preferences based on life experiences: where you grew up, the music your parents listened to, the music you were exposed to in school, what your friends listen to, what associations you have with certain kinds of music, etc., etc., etc.
But I would say that musicians are people who are keenly aware of the details of these preferences, and who play music specifically to engage deeper with these preferences, driven mad until we can create the sounds we hear internally, and who feel them so intensely there is no option but to cultivate them.
The borders between genres have been breaking down for a long time, and my favorite music barrels through the borders by using the specifically crafted elements of music that make the soul sing for those particular musicians.
If you are a musician, you have to love the music that you make. You have to actively and unapologetically craft the sound that you want to hear the most, remaining accepting of where you are in that journey, and what the best sounds are that you’re currently capable of, and then play that song with every cell and keep dreaming of the music you will make.
Sometimes the best you can do is talk around something and name its attributes when ultimately it is an indescribable direct experience. I set out thinking about this question as if I would be able to come up with a formula but now, with one hour left of Olive Tiger’s Summer Residency at Lonesome Noise, I have to leave the ruminating there.
Thank you, thank you, thank you, to Chris & the rest of the Lonesome Noise crew for allowing us to reflect and expound at length this past week about our experiences as musicians, and for everything you all do to support CT music.
Much love and gratitude,
Olive
(and Dane and Jesse in spirit).
photo credit: Jimi Patterson
Olive Tiger plays next October 3 at the Outer Space Ballroom in Hamden, CT, with Cindertalk
www.facebook.com/olivetigermusic
www.twitter.com/olivetigermusic